Cookies on this website
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you click 'Continue' we'll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies and you won't see this message again. Click 'Find out more' for information on how to change your cookie settings.
A new tool from the EBM DataLab identifies which individual GP practices are prescribing a range of ineffective and wasteful treatments that NHS England are spotlighting. © Shutterstock / University of Oxford
Each of the 19 treatments termed ‘low priority’ by NHS England represent possible waste in our health service, due to either a lack of good-quality evidence for their safety and effectiveness, or because there’s a cheaper alternative.
- Dr Ben Goldacre, University of Oxford

A new tool by Oxford University researchers launching today on OpenPrescribing.net identifies which individual GP practices are prescribing a range of ineffective and wasteful treatments that NHS England are spotlighting.

The 19 prescription items considered as “low priority” for NHS funding are the subject of a national consultation on new commissioning guidance, and were selected based on lack of evidence of their clinical effectiveness, concerns for their safety, or cost-effectiveness grounds.

OpenPrescribing.net is the first website of its kind to enable health professionals, patients and the public to easily explore patterns of prescribing nationally, in CCGs and by individual GP practices. It is supported with funding from the NIHR Oxford Biomedical Research Centre and the NIHR School of Primary Care Research

The initiative has been developed by Dr Ben Goldacre and colleagues in the EBM DataLab at Oxford University’s Nuffield Department of Primary Care Health Sciences. It turns publicly-available raw data on every prescribed drug in the NHS into easy-to-read graphs, dashboards and maps, in a way that is clear and accessible to everyone.

Through their new tool, developed in response to the NHS consultation, Dr Goldacre’s team provide specific data and graphs on prescription activity for each of the 19 treatments advised against by NHS England, at each individual GP practice in the country. An accompanying report shows total spend and trends over time.

“We think it’s good for everyone to be able to see what GP practices are prescribing,” said Dr Goldacre. “This helps GPs and the NHS know where they stand, and where there may be room for review. But it’s also valuable for patients, journalists, commissioners of health services and the public. It gives everyone the power to scrutinise prescribing at their own GP practice and explore how they’re responding to changes in clinical evidence - and price - given the finite resources available to the NHS.”

Included in the NHS England list of low-priority items is co-proxamol, which is prescribed as a pain killer. This treatment was withdrawn from general use in 2005 following concerns about its safety and lack of additional benefit when compared with paracetamol. However it continues to be prescribed, and since withdrawal its price has risen significantly, from £1.50 per pack in 2005 to £115 per pack today. Prescriptions for co-proxamol cost the NHS in England more than £7.6 million over the past year.

Also included is homeopathy, a treatment with no evidence base for its effectiveness except as a placebo, according to a 2010 report by the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee. While the report recommends that routine prescription of homeopathy by the NHS “should not continue”, over the past year homeopathy has been prescribed at least once by over 700 GP practices.

“Overall there may be good reasons for individual patients to receive some of these treatments, but in many cases where we have identified outliers there will be room for improvement. Easily accessible data is the key to improving quality. Each of the 19 treatments termed ‘low priority’ by NHS England represent possible waste in our health service, due to either a lack of good-quality evidence for their safety and effectiveness, or because there’s a cheaper alternative,” said Dr Goldacre.

OpenPrescribing.net takes the raw datasets on GP practice prescribing from NHS Digital and processes them into a user-friendly dashboard tool. This data is updated monthly and has been in the public domain under an Open Government License since 2010. The OpenPrescribing website is very widely used, with over 50,000 users and 250,000 analysis pages served over the past year.

 

The views expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of the NIHR, the NHS or the Department of Health.

Read more

Data on each of the 19 “low priority” treatments can be found here: https://openprescribing.net/measure/lpzomnibus 

By viewing an individual CCG’s page, users can then access prescribing data at individual practices within that CCG.

A report detailing time trends and more can be viewed here: https://ebmdatalab.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/NHS-19-variation.pdf

Researcher profiles:

Similar stories

Early birth linked to greater risk of hospital visits during childhood

Policy & health systems Research methods & EBM

Findings indicate that gestational age at birth is a strong predictor of ill health throughout childhood

Study provides new estimates of breast cancer risks associated with HRT

Big data Cancer QResearch

Results add to existing knowledge and should help doctors and women make the best treatment choices

New risk model estimates likelihood of hospitalisation or death from COVID-19

Big data COVID-19 Infection & acute care

A new risk model, developed by UK researchers to predict a person’s risk of being admitted to hospital and dying from Covid-19 has been published by The BMJ

Updated Cochrane Review shows electronic cigarettes can help people quit smoking but more evidence is needed on long-term harms

Health behaviours Research methods & EBM

Newly updated Cochrane evidence published today in the Cochrane Library finds that electronic cigarettes containing nicotine could increase the number of people who stop smoking compared to nicotine replacement therapy – such as chewing gum and patches – and compared to no treatment, or electronic cigarettes without nicotine. More information is needed on harms.

Oxfordshire-based SCAN pathway wins BMJ award

Awards & appointments Health Services Research

A pathway designed to investigate individuals with non-specific but concerning symptoms of cancer wins the BMJ Awards 2020 Cancer Care Team of the Year.

Gender differences in heart failure care need to be addressed

Big data Cardiovascular & metabolic

Women tend to be diagnosed with heart failure five years older than men, but have a better prognosis, finds research published in the European Journal of Heart Failure.